The Nashville Predators have faced significant challenges for the second consecutive year, and it’s time for Barry Trotz to acknowledge that his aggressive free-agent acquisitions in the 2024 offseason fell short. The seasoned GM brought in players like Steven Stamkos, Jonathan Marchessault, and Brady Skjei, which initially seemed like a promising move. This followed last offseason’s additions of Ryan O’Reilly, Gustav Nyquist, and Luke Schenn. Despite these efforts, the team’s performance this season has been disappointing, and the current results remain unacceptable.
Presently, the Predators are ranked 31st in the league, and Trotz might need to concede defeat. With rising talent like Gavin McKenna expected to be drafted soon, the team faces even tougher times ahead, potentially becoming sellers. The long-term, hefty contracts signed by older players complicate the Predators’ ability to turn things around quickly.
On Thursday, two Predators scouts observed the Montreal Canadiens vs. Washington Capitals game from the Bell Center press gallery, stirring speculation about the Preds’ players. TSN insider Pierre LeBrun indicated there may be interest from Canadian teams in Marchessault. The winger, nearly 35, is in his second year of a five-year contract worth $5.5 million annually. Although Marchessault mentioned the Canadiens’ interest, he cast doubt on their willingness to offer a similar long-term deal. With his current injuries and modest production of 6 points in 17 games, the wisdom of taking such a contract remains questionable.
Similar concerns apply to Stamkos, who, at 35, has two years remaining on an $8 million cap hit but has managed only 5 points in 20 games this season, far from his prime performance. Conversely, Ryan O’Reilly looks more appealing, especially as the Canadiens face depth issues at center following Jake Evans’ ejection for a high hit. Despite being 34, O’Reilly contributes solidly with 13 points in 20 games and a 56.4% faceoff win rate. His $4.5 million contract, with at least one year remaining, does not include a no-trade clause, making a trade feasible if the Preds choose.
While O’Reilly is a valuable player and the team’s second-leading scorer, trading him would be a significant move, considering the Predators currently have only six players with double-digit points this season. The Canadiens could benefit from his presence, especially with their recent draft gains, including multiple early-round picks. However, with the trade market slow and the Predators desperate for improvement, Trotz might hold out for a substantial return. The Predators remain a team to watch as the season progresses.
Fan Take: This situation highlights the fine balance GM Trotz faces between rebuilding and competing, a challenge resonating with many NHL fans. How the Predators navigate their roster decisions this season could influence not just their future, but also the broader dynamics of player trades and team strategies across the league.
