Kyle Tucker stands out as the top free-agent hitter available this offseason, with the Mets actively pursuing the All-Star outfielder. According to former Mets GM and MLB Network analyst Jim Duquette, the Mets, , and Blue Jays are the primary contenders for Tucker. However, Duquette noted that no deals seem imminent, and other interested teams appear less competitive compared to these three.
The Athletic’s Mitch Bannon reported that Toronto is intensifying its efforts to sign Tucker, who fits their roster better than former infielder Beau Bichette. After signing Japanese star Kazuma Okamoto, the Blue Jays’ infield seems settled, but there’s room to strengthen their outfield. Adding Tucker could allow Anthony Santander to move to left field, while George Springer would primarily serve as the designated hitter.
The Blue Jays made their initial pitch by inviting Tucker to their player development complex in Florida earlier this December. Since then, the reigning American League champions have made several roster moves, including acquiring pitchers Dylan Stoppelman, Tyler Rogers, and adding Okamoto as a free agent.
For the Mets, Tucker fits perfectly after trading Brandon Nimmo to the Rangers, opening up left field. Currently, Tyrone Taylor is in center field and Juan Soto in right. Prospect Carson Benge might join the outfield in 2026, but signing Tucker would provide the Mets with two powerful corner outfield bats immediately.
Tucker’s ultimate choice will likely hinge on salary. Recent reports suggest he could command a higher average annual value (AAV) on a shorter contract this offseason and then re-enter free agency in a few years. Thus, signing with the Jays, Mets, or may suit him best.
While the Mets are linked to Tucker, they might also consider Cody Bellinger, who offers defensive flexibility at first base. Bellinger has been highly sought by the Yankees, who have made him two contract offers, though negotiations are still ongoing.
Fan Take: This offseason’s pursuit of Kyle Tucker is captivating as it has the potential to reshape the balance of power in MLB. Adding a player of Tucker’s caliber could dramatically influence team dynamics and excitement for fans, making the upcoming season one to watch closely.
