The offseason is progressing steadily, and while the Yankees have already scored big by re-signing Cody Bellinger, they still have room for improvement. One potential addition could be another right-handed hitter for the infield, providing balance against their predominantly left-handed lineup. This would be a complementary acquisition, but adding depth is always beneficial, and Ty France could be a strong candidate for the Yankees.
France, a seasoned player, has proven himself as a solid major league hitter and is currently on track to claim his first Gold Glove Award. Although it’s uncertain if his peak performance lies ahead, he remains a valuable target for many teams, including New York.
2025 Stats: 138 games, 490 plate appearances, .257/.320/.360, 7 home runs, 52 RBIs, 92 wRC+, 10 outs above average, 0.9 fWAR
2026 FanGraphs Projection: 78 games, 336 plate appearances, .252/.321/.383, 8 home runs, 38 RBIs, 98 wRC+, 0.5 fWAR
France debuted with the Padres at age 24 in 2019, initially showing modest results. However, in the shortened 2020 season, he stood out with a 133 wRC+ over 43 games split between San Diego and Seattle. By 2021, now in a full-time role with the Mariners, France truly broke out, delivering 18 homers, a .368 on-base average, and a 129 wRC+. He kept up strong production the following year, hitting over 20 homers for the first time and earning an All-Star nod.
During those three seasons, France performed at an All-Star caliber, even if he wasn’t officially recognized every year. Since then, however, his value has diminished. In 2023, playing mainly first base for Seattle, his power declined, and though still above average offensively, his overall output dropped.
France has since moved between several teams—Seattle, Cincinnati, Minnesota, and Toronto—without much success at the plate. Over the last two seasons, his hitting has dipped below average with a sub-90 OPS+, less frequent on-base appearances, and decreased power. While these trends are concerning, they don’t tell the entire story.
Remarkably, France has reinvented himself as a top-notch defender at first base. After ranking in the 1st percentile with a -12 OAA in 2024, he took home his first Gold Glove last year with a stellar 96th percentile 10 OAA. If he can sustain this elite defensive level alongside his contact hitting, he’ll still provide solid value, even if a full offensive resurgence seems unlikely.
For the Yankees, adding France makes sense given their interest in experienced players. A dependable right-handed batter to complement Ben Rice at first base and step in when Rice moves to the outfield would be a valuable asset. France’s skill set fits this role perfectly.
Now 31, France’s contact-focused approach suggests he may be past his prime offensively, but his sudden defensive brilliance keeps hopes for continued contributions alive. Given his recent struggles, he likely won’t command a hefty salary and may need to accept a supporting role. This low-risk acquisition could be a smart move for New York.
Fan Take:
Adding a player like Ty France could provide the Yankees with crucial infield depth and right-handed balance, enhancing their lineup versatility. For baseball fans, this move highlights the ongoing importance of well-rounded, defense-first players in a game often dominated by offensive stats.
