The Toronto Maple Leafs are gearing up for a pivotal off-season, with potential major changes on the horizon. General manager Brad Treliving has hinted that the team’s roster might need a significant shake-up following a disappointing and brief playoff run.
The 2024-25 Leafs came close to breaking through a longstanding playoff barrier by nearly reaching the conference finals for the first time since 2002. However, they lost a 2-0 series lead against the Florida Panthers and were ultimately defeated in a decisive Game 7 during the second round. At a press conference after the season, Treliving emphasized the necessity for new “DNA” from the 2025-26 season forward, stating, “If you keep getting the same result, there’s some DNA that needs to be changed.”
For almost ten years, the Maple Leafs’ success has hinged on their core group of four players — Auston Matthews, William Nylander, Mitch Marner, and John Tavares. Despite many regular-season wins, they’ve only managed to win two playoff series. Currently, Marner and Tavares are poised to become unrestricted free agents, while promising player Matthew Neese is set to become a restricted free agent after an impressive season with 29 goals and 29 assists. Managing to retain all these key players will be challenging given salary cap limitations and mounting fan expectations. Additionally, after the decision to part ways with President Brendan Shanahan, attention is now squarely on the team’s roster.
Retaining the entire core might prove difficult, especially considering Marner’s value following a 100-point season, which will likely attract significant attention in free agency. Despite it possibly being unpopular among fans, Toronto may need to make tough decisions about trading some players. Given a weak free agent market and limited draft assets, this strategic approach might ultimately be the most prudent path forward.
—
Fan Take: This off-season marks a critical juncture for the Maple Leafs and their supporters, as the franchise seeks to evolve beyond past playoff frustrations. The moves made now could redefine the team’s identity and influence the competitive landscape of the NHL for years to come, making it must-watch drama for all hockey fans.
