On July 30th and 31st, 2005, the NHL conducted its draft, which had initially been planned for June 25th but was postponed due to a lockout. Following the lottery draft on July 22nd, the order was set, granting the Pittsburgh Penguins the opportunity to select Sidney Crosby. Meanwhile, the Montreal Canadiens secured the fifth overall pick.
With top prospects like Crosby, Bobby Ryan, Jack Johnson, and Benoit Priott off the board, the Canadiens chose to take a chance on their fifth pick, a decision that would ultimately reshape the franchise. The goaltender they selected became the team’s cornerstone for 15 years, earning a place in history as one of the greatest netminders with 361 wins.
Despite facing challenges like the departures of players Armia and Dvorak, the Canadiens consistently made the playoffs in 10 of the 15 years while relying heavily on this goaltender, who was a vital presence despite the team’s overall lack of offensive firepower. Although he never led them to a Stanley Cup victory, his skill and talent were undeniable, and success might have come with stronger team support.
Much criticism surrounds the large contract signed by the goaltender, which consumed a significant portion of the salary cap, but this was a move any management would likely have made. The Canadiens’ management, under Mark Bergevin, also invested heavily in building a strong defensive unit, focusing on large, physical defenders.
The mantra “You just have to make the playoffs, anything can happen” didn’t quite hold true, as Stanley Cup winners usually are teams that dominate the regular season rather than just scraping in. Achieving ultimate success in the NHL requires careful planning and a strategic mindset, something that might have been different if the goaltender had been supported by more offensive talent or had avoided career-ending injuries.
Photo credit: Eric Bolte-Immagn Image
For more Canadiens stories, analysis, and updates, bookmark the Hockey News Canadiens page and join the conversation on the Canadians Roundtable.
Fan Take: This draft decision marked a pivotal moment in Canadiens history, showing how one strategic pick can influence a franchise for over a decade. Hockey fans should recognize the importance of balancing talent across the roster to truly contend for the Stanley Cup, as star players need strong support to reach their full potential.
