When Trinity Rodman lined up along the sideline at PayPal Park during the NWSL Championship’s 56th minute, it was evident she was delivering what the audience had eagerly anticipated. The crowd erupted, with their cheers soaring above the usual noise of live events, marking the most thunderous moment of the evening.
Rodman is a prominent figure in women’s soccer, drawing fans from all corners of the nation and influencing many to tune in on Saturday nights. Jessica Berman, the NWSL’s Elite Athletes Commissioner, emphasized that the league is determined to keep such impactful players, as they are crucial for its evolution. Rodman has the ability to change the game, yet, with about 30 minutes left to play, she had not scored.
However, the focus on her star power didn’t translate into success. Gotham FC’s 1-0 victory over the Washington Spirit illustrated their remarkable talent in dismantling defenses, regardless of the challenges they faced. Even with strong players like Gift Monday, Croix Bethune, and Sofia Cantore taking the field before Rodman joined, the Spirit found themselves with just 0.49 expected goals and no shots on target. Rodman, coming back from an MCL sprain, couldn’t find her rhythm and ended the match without attempting a shot.
This scenario hints at the NWSL’s valuable asset: the array of stars and champions across its 14 teams. The game’s dynamic was highlighted by Rose Lavelle’s 80th-minute winning goal, showcasing individual excellence. Gotham also encountered offensive struggles, managing only 0.39 expected goals themselves, signaling a need for a playmaker. Lavelle, known for her pivotal role in the Women’s World Cup final six years ago, shone once more, securing her first NWSL title and MVP honors.
Gotham is equally talented as the Spirit. Jadyn Shaw contributed significantly, scoring three of her four playoff goals, while international champions like goalkeeper Anne-Katrin Berger and center-back Emily Sonnet also delivered impressive performances. Despite entering the postseason as the lowest seed, they defied the “underdog” label and fulfilled expectations by clinching their second title.
The unpredictability among such a star-studded roster keeps fans engaged, as individual talent is bound to shine, albeit unpredictably. The excitement of this uncertainty is one of the NWSL’s most appealing qualities, regardless of player turnover. Currently, the league boasts numerous high-profile athletes, though Rodman’s situation exemplifies that not all stars hold the same influence.
The NWSL is in a pivotal transition, with legends like Alex Morgan and Megan Rapinoe concluding their illustrious careers and paving the way for new talent. As the next generation emerges, Rodman is a standout leader. Her skills, accolades, and the unique combination of qualities she brings make her one of the most sought-after players globally. While it’s uncertain where she’ll end up, it’s clear her future is vital for the NWSL, especially with the 2025 season approaching.
Rodman hasn’t yet made her choice, but Saturday’s performance was likely a rehearsal for what lies ahead. Interested in both England’s Women’s Super League and the American Division I league USL Super League, she seems focused on her NWSL fate. Renewing salary cap regulations that constrain her return to the Spirit might allow Rodman to continue her partnership with the NWSL, fostering mutual growth as women’s sports gain traction. If she chooses to play elsewhere, navigating the NWSL’s transitional phase would become much more daunting.
Rodman’s underwhelming performance may not have reflected her star status, but the enthusiasm of the 18,000 fans in San Jose highlighted the stakes for the NWSL as it embarks on a new era for women’s soccer. The asking price has shifted from mere acknowledgment to demanding substantial, thoughtful investments. The league’s forthcoming choices regarding Rodman and others will shape the foundation for future stars, whether they currently reside in the NWSL or aspire to join.
Fan Take: Rodman’s presence and potential exit illustrate the ongoing evolution in women’s soccer, emphasizing the need for the NWSL to adapt and invest in its stars. As the league transitions, the retention of premier talent like Rodman is essential in maintaining momentum and capturing fan support, ensuring the sport’s continued growth.
