Age is just a number for Max Scherzer, who at 41, continues to prove his high-level pitching performance. Last season, Scherzer was a key part of the Toronto Blue Jays’ starting rotation and shone in the postseason with a 3.77 ERA across three starts, including two in the World Series. Teams interested in signing this future Hall of Famer would likely value him as a veteran presence to solidify their starting rotation, a role Scherzer has excelled in recently.
If Scherzer were to leave Toronto, here are three teams that would be ideal fits:
First, the Baltimore Orioles, who had a surprising 96-win season in 2023-24 after a disappointing 75-win year in 2025. Their starting rotation struggled last season, ranking near the bottom in ERA and WHIP, and with veteran pitchers leaving, they need a strong addition. Scherzer, with his arsenal of pitches and experience, would bring leadership and skill to help guide their talented but inconsistent rotation.
Second, the San Diego Padres have a vacancy in their rotation and could benefit greatly from Scherzer’s presence. With several pitchers hitting free agency and an injury to Yu Darvish expected to keep him out for 2026, the Padres need reliable arms. Scherzer, an eight-time All-Star, can provide stability and postseason experience while mentoring younger pitchers on the team.
Lastly, the Cincinnati Reds, a team close to competing but often falling short, could gain from Scherzer’s veteran savvy. With several pitchers becoming free agents and a solid but still developing rotation, Scherzer’s postseason experience and pitching expertise would be invaluable. Even on a one-year deal, he could help the Reds both on the mound and in mentoring emerging talents.
Fan Take: Max Scherzer’s ability to remain a top-tier pitcher at 41 is remarkable and highlights the value of experience in baseball. His potential move to any of these teams could not only boost their rotations but also inspire young players, adding excitement and depth to the sport’s competitive landscape.
