During the offseason, CBS Sports’ MLB experts host weekly “Batting Around” roundtables where they discuss a wide range of topics, including the latest news, historical perspectives, and future possibilities in baseball. Two weeks ago, they considered the chance of a Nolan Arenado trade, and this week they are preparing for the upcoming Winter Meetings.
When asked who might be the best player traded at the Winter Meetings, Dane Perry suggests it’s unlikely Tarik Skubal will be moved this offseason, making a trade during the meetings even less probable. He believes the Yankees could acquire Brendan Donovan from the Cardinals in exchange for a package focused on young pitchers. Donovan is a solid left-handed hitter who can play multiple positions and excels defensively at second base, fitting well with the Yankees’ needs.
RJ Anderson agrees with the focus on the National League Central and picks Freddy Peralta as a possible trade candidate. With Milwaukee managing payroll after bringing back Brandon Woodruff, the Brewers have a history of trading quality pitchers like Corbin Burnes and Devin Williams for valuable returns. Anderson thinks teams might decide it’s smarter to meet Milwaukee’s asking price for Peralta rather than settling for a less talented free agent.
Matt Snyder aligns with RJ, emphasizing that Peralta might be having a standout year but with only one year of team control left before free agency, the Brewers could entertain offers. Despite Peralta’s age of 30, his recent performance metrics suggest a possible regression, but Milwaukee’s front office is known for its savvy dealings and will likely make moves if strong offers come their way.
Mike Axisa brings up an outside-the-box pick: Twins’ player Louis Lewis. Lewis had a challenging 2025 but has shown flashes of great potential. The Twins, aiming to reduce payroll following aggressive trading at the deadline, might consider trading Lewis despite his modest $3 million arbitration salary and three years of team control. Axisa sees a scenario where a good offer could tempt the Twins to move him.
Fan Take: This insider look at potential trades highlights the intense strategic moves teams are contemplating to shape their rosters for success. For baseball fans, these trades can signal shifts in power and surprise breakout performances, keeping the sport dynamic and exciting.
