The 2025 Eastern Conference Finals highlighted the disappointing performance of the New York Knicks, especially their starting lineup of Jalen Brunson, Josh Hart, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and Karl-Anthony Towns. While this group logged the most minutes in the playoffs with 940 total, their overall effectiveness waned over time. New York’s starters have surpassed 50 points only a few times in 308 postseason minutes and were outscored by double digits in nearly half of their playoff games. The lineup has struggled notably in the Eastern Conference Finals, contributing to the Knicks falling behind 0-2 in their series against the Pacers.
In a notable adjustment for Game 3, Mitchell Robinson replaced Josh Hart in the starting lineup. Robinson, who contributed 41 points in 273 minutes during the postseason, brings strengths that align with the Knicks’ needs. The Knicks excel in rebounding, ranking ninth in the NBA, even without Robinson, while the Pacers rank near the bottom. Despite returning from injury and limited conditioning, Robinson played significant minutes in Game 2, demonstrating that starting him allows better rest management during games. His presence on the floor early in quarters hampers opponents’ ability to foul strategically, and his defensive capabilities provide the Knicks with more flexible matchup options against players like Pascal Siakam and Miles Turner.
Conversely, Hart’s energy off the bench remains valuable, particularly against the strong Pacer bench. Incorporating Hart back into the second unit alongside players like Deuce McBride could reinforce the Knicks’ depth and offer better ball handling during critical moments.
Coach Tom Thibodeau’s strict reliance on the same starting lineup throughout the season—12 different lineups in 96 games, the fewest in the NBA—reflects his traditional approach. However, the recent home losses in this best-of-seven series have forced the team to rethink their starting group in hopes of turning the series around.
Fan Take: This lineup shakeup is crucial for Knicks fans anxious about their team’s Finals hopes, as it showcases the delicate balance between player health, defensive strategy, and maintaining energy levels. For basketball fans in general, it underscores how tactical adjustments, even around player roles and minutes, can significantly influence playoff outcomes and exemplifies the evolving nature of coaching strategies in the NBA.
