Despite the recent expansion of the MLB postseason, most teams still fall short of reaching impactful October baseball. As the 2026 season progresses, several teams have already been knocked out of playoff contention, and we’re monitoring those whose paths to October glory have effectively ended as of September 9.
Athletics:
The Athletics experienced a brief moment of optimism when they were three games above .500 in early May and notably spent 45 days atop the AL West division. However, that promising start quickly faded, and by September 9, they became the fourth team to be eliminated after a dismal 32-60 run. Injuries played a major role, with key players like Nick Kurtz, Shea Langeliers, Brent Rookier, Tyler Soderstrom, and Jacob Wilson all sidelined for significant periods, severely impacting the team’s performance. Despite having offensive firepower when healthy, the combination of injuries, pitching struggles, and playing in a challenging ballpark led to their downfall.
San Francisco Giants:
The Giants had high expectations with new manager Tony Vitello bringing a lively collegiate approach, but those hopes were undercut by inconsistent leadership and an overall mediocre roster. Rafael Devers was a standout performer, scorching from May through early September with a slash line of .273/.365/.585, launching 35 homers and leading MLB in doubles despite playing in a pitchers’ park. Rookie DH Bryce Eldridge also showed promise, but beyond these two, the lineup was largely uninspiring. On the mound, Robbie Ray was the only pitcher performing above average—and he was traded mid-season—leaving the team in desperate need of a rebuild.
Los Angeles Angels:
The Angels’ early elimination was predictable, as they traded away assets at the deadline to focus on rebuilding. Mike Trout remained mostly healthy and productive, though not quite at his peak, yet the team’s overall stagnation made it impossible to contend. The franchise is entering a “fresh start” era under new owner Stan Kroenke, underscored by acquiring promising prospects like shortstop Arjun Nimmala, who became the team’s top positional prospect upon arrival. Patience will be key as the Angels chart a new course in 2027 and beyond.
Colorado Rockies:
The Rockies were not expected to be playoff contenders in 2026, given their recent history of losing over 100 games in three straight seasons. Avoiding the 100-loss mark this year marks progress, especially under new leadership from GM Josh Byrnes and president Paul Depodesta. First baseman TJ Rumfield and outfielder Cole Carrigg have been standout rookies, while catcher Hunter Goodman’s power surge offers hope for building a competitive core. Although the Rockies remain a struggling team, their gradual improvement provides a foundation for future success and keeps fans hopeful.
Fan Take:
These team eliminations highlight how injuries, leadership, and roster depth can dramatically shape a season’s outcome. For baseball fans, this period of rebuilding and transition across multiple franchises underscores the sport’s enduring unpredictability and the excitement of watching teams evolve toward future competitiveness.
Source: www.foxsports.com
