PITTSBURGH — While Aaron Rodgers has insisted that “no one is hostage,” the Pittsburgh Steelers initially planned to handle their offseason moves independently of his decision. Yet, their actions didn’t quite align with those statements.
Rodgers enjoyed time with friends and rapper Mike at the Kentucky Derby party, dealing with what he called “difficult” circumstances within his inner circle. Meanwhile, the Steelers largely overlooked quarterback options until selecting Wil Howard in the sixth round of the draft. They also signed Mason Rudolph as the sole experienced quarterback alongside the less seasoned Skyler Thompson.
Coach Mike Tomlin believes players should be “volunteers, not hostages,” but ironically, the Steelers seem reliant on Rodgers’ uncertain status. With the draft complete, a scarce free-agent quarterback market, and limited trade opportunities, Rodgers remains their pivotal hope. On paper and in practice, however, Rodgers doesn’t quite fit the Steelers’ traditional play style or organizational values, leaving the team facing an identity dilemma.
Tomlin highlighted the importance of becoming a run-first team when he brought in offensive coordinator Arthur Smith last year, yet the Steelers appear ready to sign Rodgers—who ranked second in passing attempts last NFL season—on Friday. Tomlin also values quarterback mobility, yet Rodgers faced 40 sacks and ran only 34 times for 94 yards last season. General manager Omar Khan managed a significant trade to bring in deep-threat receiver DK Metcalf, extending his contract despite Rodgers posting an average of just 6.6 air yards per pass attempt last year, ranking near the bottom in the league.
Khan acknowledged the team’s underwhelming finish last season, stating at the NFL Combine, “We know we have to get better, people expect better. We expect better, and it can’t happen again. I’m as disappointed as everyone else, and we’re working hard to fix it.”
The Steelers entered the offseason after a promising five-game winning streak, ending the year 10-3 over 14 weeks. Rodgers, poised to become the team’s fifth different Week 1 starter, may not fit the intended offensive identity.
This marks the Steelers’ second attempt at quarterback rejuvenation. Similar to 36-year-old Russell Wilson, Rodgers, now 41, was released by the New York Jets before his contract expired. Pittsburgh benefited by not re-signing Wilson, who signed a modest deal with the Jets, with Rodgers’ modest average annual contract reflecting a fresh start.
After the Giants signed Wilson and Minnesota drafted first-round quarterback JJ McCarthy, Pittsburgh secured Rodgers following a contentious decision period where he debated retirement. But at this stage, Rodgers faces many challenges.
A four-time NFL MVP, 10-time Pro Bowler, and Super Bowl champion (who defeated Tomlin’s Steelers), Rodgers is undoubtedly a future Hall of Famer. However, after an Achilles injury, a 2023 season, and mixed success in New York, Rodgers arrives amid a decline from his MVP peak.
Since his MVP seasons, Rodgers’ performance has dropped, ranking in the mid-20s for QBR and interception rates. His time with the Jets included uneven play, culminating in a 40-14 loss to the Bills and a lackluster offense.
The Steelers similarly struggled offensively last year, failing to score a touchdown on opening drives all season and enduring a dry spell of 20 offensive possessions without a touchdown.
Tomlin admitted, “We certainly need to score more points. You don’t win games scoring 14 points a week in January.”
Comparatively, Wilson’s skill set better matched Pittsburgh’s offense: he averaged more yards per attempt and performed efficiently under pressure.
Rodgers has become more cautious post-injury, throwing shorter passes and averaging slower decision times. The Jets’ offense ranked 28th in rushing last year, whereas Smith, Rodgers’ new coordinator, has led multiple top rushing offenses.
Wilson is exploring options with other teams as the Steelers await Rodgers’ choice. After Wilson’s visit news broke, Pittsburgh re-signed Rudolph, reinforcing their quarterback depth.
Some see Rodgers as a riskier option than Wilson or believe other quarterback candidates offer better value. The Jets boasted a higher red-zone scoring efficiency than Pittsburgh last year.
Steelers cornerback Brandin Echols, who played with Rodgers last season, commented, “He played well, especially towards the end of the season. I hope his performance continued to improve; he really woke up late in the year.”
Ultimately, the Steelers’ offseason strategy hinges on Rodgers’ return and fitting him effectively into their offensive scheme to avoid an identity crisis.
—
Fan Take: This development is crucial for NFL fans as it highlights the complex challenge teams face when blending veteran talent with evolving offensive philosophies. Rodgers’ move to Pittsburgh could reshape the Steelers’ future and influence how older elite quarterbacks are integrated into new team identities in the league.
