It is what it is, friends. Ange Postecoglou was removed from his position on Friday, as Tottenham Hotspur confirmed what many had speculated for some time.
Following a long wait of 17 years, Spurs celebrated victory in the UEFA Europa League with a 1-0 win over Manchester United in last month’s final. Postecoglou had insisted they would secure silverware in his second season with the team.
However, the board deemed his tactics too costly. The Spurs faced 22 defeats in the Premier League— a record for non-relegated teams— and finished in a disappointing 17th place.
The official message upon his dismissal conveyed gratitude alongside pointed observations.
“After a positive start to the 2023-24 Premier League season, I managed 78 points from my last 66 PL matches,” it stated. “This culminated last season with our lowest PL finish.
“Injuries and the growing focus on European competitions contributed to this situation. Winning the Europa League was a significant milestone, but our decisions cannot be shaped by fleeting emotions tied to this victory.”
And they indeed did not.
Postecoglou’s final address during an open-top bus parade playfully remarked, “As with the best TV shows, Season 3 often surpasses Season 2.” Yet, the financial decision-makers ended his tenure.
According to ESPN, Tottenham’s journey with this record-setting coach was complicated.
Strong Start
Postecoglou’s tenure began amid turmoil. On his first day, star striker Harry Kane expressed his desire to leave the club.
Kane ultimately transferred to Bayern Munich for €120 million just before the Premier League season kicked off. While Spurs initially stumbled, they quickly became unpredictable.
With eight wins and two draws in the first ten games, Tottenham sat atop the Premier League, exuding a sense of liberation. The fanbase, tired of the regression under Antonio Conte, felt a revival as the team delivered on goals, press, and overall dynamism. By late September, Levy informed the fan forum that “Tottenham is back.”
Postecoglou made history as the first Premier League manager to win Manager of the Month awards three times consecutively at the season’s start.
Yet, his first loss was an unexpected defeat, with Spurs falling 4-1 to Chelsea in chaotic circumstances—two red cards, injuries, and multiple VAR checks. Despite being reduced to nine players, Spurs showcased a determined commitment to “Angeball,” earning fans’ respect.
Former manager Mauricio Pochettino, beloved by many Spurs supporters during his five-and-a-half-year stint, was on the opposing side, greeted not with anger but with a reworked version of Robbie Williams’ song, “The Angels.” The sentiments were clear.
Season Wrap-Up and Future Hopes
However, Spurs struggled to maintain that early-season momentum. Winning only two of their last seven matches prevented them from qualifying for the UEFA Champions League, leading to a scenario where many fans hoped for a loss against Manchester City to thwart their title chase.
“The foundation is quite fragile,” he commented after the May 14th match.
Sources indicate that Postecoglou pointed to a prevailing lack of a winning mentality as part of the problem, believing he had recognized a deeper issue within the club related to their inability to seize control over their destiny.
This sentiment was evident when he famously stated after a 1-0 defeat to Arsenal in September, “I fix myself—I don’t usually win things; I tend to secure titles in my second year.” He embraced the backlash, using it as motivation to implement change. He hoped the Spurs would build the confidence to pursue silverware, something they had not consistently achieved due to psychological barriers.
There are indications that this mindset contributed to subsequent challenges, as he believed demonstrating a rigorous style was the only way to win over skeptics questioning his compatibility with British football.
1:21
What led to Spurs parting ways with Ange Postecoglou?
An analysis of the factors behind Tottenham’s decision to let go of Postecoglou despite the Europa League victory.
Injuries and Unrest
Injuries plagued the Spurs as the season wore on.
Notable absences included key defenders Christian Romero and Mickey Van Deven for nearly four months, while goalkeeper Guglielmo Viario faced a three-month layoff. Richarlison missed two separate two-month stretches, and Destiny Udogie was sidelined for six weeks. Key players Dejan Kulusevski, James Maddison, and Lucas Bergvall all missed the campaign’s finale.
While Postecoglou attempted to cope with these challenges, sources indicate some within the club began to question the effectiveness of his methods. Although some injuries were unfortunate, the team’s high defensive line and intensive sprint demands could have contributed to muscle injuries.
The club’s sports science and medical staff underwent a shake-up in the summer of 2024, with performance director Adam Brett taking the lead. Reports suggest that discussions about reassessing the medical team following Postecoglou’s exit signal ongoing concerns.
The January transfer window was critical.
While Postecoglou advocated for reinforcements, Tottenham made only last-minute signings—a fallback outfielder (Lens Kevin Danso) and Slavia-Prague goalkeeper Antonin Kinski. A loan from Bayern Munich for promising Matiss Tell was too much to expect, especially mid-season.
Postecoglou later clarified that during this period, he chose to prioritize the Europa League. This decision did not have unanimous support within the club as some felt focused sacrifice was necessary for a better Premier League performance.
There was discontent regarding Postecoglou’s training methods. Some players expressed concerns about the team’s open style, questioning the focus on their play instead of tailored strategies against specific opponents. The absence of a dedicated set-piece coach provided an easy target for criticism.
Despite regular media exposure, Postecoglou maintained a warm and approachable demeanor in press conferences. He was candid about various issues, notably VAR, but many regarded his failure to engage modern set-piece tactics as a misstep since the team consistently struggled with dead-ball situations.
This predictability allowed rival teams to exploit weaknesses, particularly when fullbacks pushed up, leaving Spurs vulnerable during transitions.
Your Postecoglou began to show signs of strain as mounting pressure took its toll. After a disallowed equalizer at Chelsea in early April, he faced backlash, particularly from away fans. Despite his attempts to explain the call, few were convinced.
Building tensions were evident, especially away from home. He faced significant disapproval after another disappointing performance against AFC Bournemouth in December. However, insiders reported that he maintained strong support within the locker room, admired for his motivational techniques and personal touch.
Postecoglou often stepped back, allowing assistants to run training sessions to maximize the impact of pre-match talks. His final address before the Europa League Final, featuring special videos with messages from players’ families, showcased his thoughtful approach. Although he did not play favorites, he occasionally displayed a personal side.
Reports indicate that an April contract renewal for Bergval was influenced not by an existing agreement but by aspirations for internal success. Sources suggest Postecoglou’s involvement and significant interaction with the player’s family during negotiations.
Bitter End
Postecoglou addressed the final weeks of the season as someone aware that his tenure was ending, irrespective of the Europa League final’s outcome.
The Spurs’ performance had become uncharacteristically cautious, more aligned with defensive discipline than the free-flowing play associated with “Angeball.” Ironically, this was reflective of their continental play in later stages against Eintracht Frankfurt and Bodeau/Grimt, proving his adaptability.
Some questioned whether this shift stemmed from excessive pressure. Regardless, Postecoglou provided one of the club’s most memorable nights, fostering unity despite a challenging domestic run.
Post-victory, Postecoglou confessed uncertainty regarding his future, affirming in his last press conference that he could hold his head high regardless of the outcome.
Celebrating with over 200,000 fans during a trophy parade solidified his legacy as a manager who delivered Tottenham’s most memorable moments in nearly two decades. Despite current divisions within the fanbase, he will always be celebrated upon his return.
Nevertheless, Levy believed Postecoglou’s methods were too volatile. Following the final celebration, there was an inclination that his high-risk approach would not yield the sustained success Tottenham had long sought.
For years, the Spurs leadership faced criticism for lacking the ambition necessary to win trophies, compromising quality for financial stability or pragmatism. Ultimately, Postecoglou embodied this dilemma, highlighting it under harsh scrutiny.
The lasting sentiment, after all, is one of gratitude: Thank you for a brilliant night.
Fan Take: This news is vital to soccer fans as it underscores the harsh realities of managerial decisions in top-flight football, where even silverware isn’t always a safety net. The dismissal of postecoglou could signal significant changes ahead for Spurs, influencing strategies and expectations within the broader landscape of the sport.
