A new season is on the horizon for Manchester United, and with new signings like Matheus Cunha and Brian Mbeumo, the team is setting its sights on enhancing their offense. However, there remain significant challenges, especially following a disappointing 15th place finish in the league with 18 losses, even as Marcus Rashford eyes a move to Barcelona and Alejandro Garnacho contributes to their efforts in the final Europa League campaign.
Last year was a tough one for the Red Devils, but there’s potential for improvement with a determined focus on a singular competition under a consistent management style. While there is much work required, some positive aspects are emerging as the new season approaches.
Now, what should be done regarding the players in the team? Should they be retained or transferred? Here’s a breakdown:
Transfers: Keep or Sell?
GK – Andre Onana (29)
Onana is a polarizing goalkeeper; while he has shown potential as a top shot-stopper, his inconsistencies raise concerns. Given the other pressing issues in the squad, it would be reasonable to let him go if a suitable offer comes in.
Verdict: Sell
DEF – Lenny Yoro (19)
Yoro had an injury-ridden start but showcased promise by the end of the season. With more experience, he could evolve into a solid Premier League defender, provided the defensive structure around him is strong.
Verdict: Keep
DEF – Lisandro Martinez (27)
Martinez stands out as one of United’s best defenders but struggles with injuries. Unless the club undergoes a major overhaul, retaining him seems the best option.
Verdict: Keep
DEF – Matthijs de Ligt (25)
Though de Ligt has room for improvement, he was brought in under familiar conditions with Erik Ten Hag. His contribution remains limited, especially in a densely populated squad.
Verdict: Sell
DEF – Harry Maguire (32)
Maguire played a crucial role during United’s Europa League journey. Despite being considered expensive, his experience could be valuable as the team evolves.
Verdict: Keep
DEF – Patrick Dorgu (20)
As an exciting wingback, Dorgu could thrive with a full preseason under his belt. His dual impact on offensive and defensive plays will be crucial for the upcoming season.
Verdict: Keep
DEF – Luke Shaw (30)
Shaw’s versatility benefits the team, providing much-needed depth despite his injury history. His seasoned leadership is valuable for the squad.
Verdict: Keep
DEF – Diogo Dalot (26)
Dalot’s future hinges on Amorim’s tactical decisions. If younger players are utilized in wingback roles, Dalot may find himself surplus to requirements.
Verdict: To be determined
DEF – Noussair Mazraoui (27)
Mazraoui offers depth and flexibility, particularly when playing in both defensive and midfield roles. While the team could use improvements, he is adequate for now.
Verdict: Keep
MID – Manuel Ugarte (24)
Ugarte is a good fit under Amorim, providing depth in midfield as United considers Casemiro’s age. He needs time to develop, but if he doesn’t progress this season, it might be time to move on.
Verdict: Keep
MID – Casemiro (33)
Despite expectations for Casemiro to leave, his experience remains vital. Effective squad management will be key to ensuring he contributes consistently throughout the season.
Verdict: Keep
MID – Kobbie Mainoo (20)
Mainoo is seen as a key building block for the team, capable of advancing the play significantly. Adding a scoring element to his game would enhance his contributions.
Verdict: Keep
MID – Bruno Fernandes (30)
Fernandes was instrumental last season, arguably saving United from relegation. Building the team around him and other midfielders should be a priority.
Verdict: Keep
MID – Mason Mount (26)
Mount’s constant injuries have raised doubts about his reliability. Despite previous success at Chelsea, moving forward with him appears risky.
Verdict: Sell
FWD – Alejandro Garnacho (21)
Garnacho seems destined to leave, as the team looks to add more strength in his position. His talent has not mitigated his perceived lack of necessity.
Verdict: Sell
FWD – Amad Diallo (23)
Diallo is expected to stay, as his versatility adds depth to the squad. Building on last season’s performance will be crucial for his development.
Verdict: Keep
FWD – Antony (25)
Antony’s stint at United may soon come to an end due to inconsistent performances. His time in the Premier League has not lived up to expectations.
Verdict: Sell
FWD – Rasmus Hojlund (22)
Even with a modest goal tally last season, Hojlund is seen as a player with untapped potential. It’s too early to give up on him, as this season holds significance for his development.
Verdict: Keep
FWD – Joshua Zirkzee (24)
Zirkzee has struggled and may not fit seamlessly into the squad with multiple similar strikers present. His addition to the team is now under scrutiny.
Verdict: Sell
Fan Take: This analysis is crucial for Manchester United fans as it outlines potential changes that could significantly impact the team’s performance. A revitalized squad could mean a shift in their fortunes, paving the way for a much-anticipated resurgence in domestic and European competitions.
