Jeff Caschell
Since Emma Hayes assumed the coaching reins, the US Women’s National Team has undergone an incredible phase of experimentation, reflecting an unprecedented shift for the top team in women’s soccer.
In her inaugural year, Hayes has introduced 24 players to international competition, marking their debuts in the first 24 matches, despite the team winning gold at the previous summer Olympics.
Having observed her players extensively, Hayes is now refining her core roster, aiming to build a squad capable of challenging for victory in the 2027 World Cup in Brazil.
Following this experimentation phase, we evaluate which newcomers are most likely to secure a spot on the roster for the upcoming Women’s World Cup. We’ve ranked these debutants based on how well they might fit into Hayes’ plans for 2027, factoring in both their talent and the team’s positional requirements.
24. Eva Gaetino | 22 | Defender | PSG
Gaetino’s debut was a solid 3-0 win over Argentina last year, and at just 22, she has ample time to grow. However, her consistency in the recent U23 matches has been questioned as Hayes explores other promising center-back options.
23. Sam Staab | 28 | Defender | Chicago Star FC
An NWSL stalwart, Staab encountered a severe injury shortly after debuting with the US team, posing challenges for her comeback. Competing in Chicago this year has made it hard for her to regain her spotlight.
22. Lo’eau Labonta | 32 | Midfielder | Kansas City Current
Despite being a major supporter of Labonta, she’s facing fierce competition in midfield as Hayes focuses on building a youthful squad. Nevertheless, Labonta remains an all-NWSL talent, highlighting the importance of club form in her selection.
21. Sam Meza | 23 | Midfielder | Seattle Reign FC
Meza recently impressed during her debut with Ireland, showcasing her solid midfield performance in Seattle. She possesses potential as a deeper midfielder, but faces an established group ahead of her on the depth chart.
20. Izzy Rodriguez | 26 | Defender | Kansas City Current
Rodriguez is a strong offensive presence in the NWSL, ranking 14th in the league for chances created. This offensive profile aligns with Hayes’ vision for fullbacks, although her international sample size remains limited.
19. Kelly Abelo | 25 | Defender | Orlando Pride
Similar to Rodriguez, Abelo is an attacking fullback with limited international appearances but brings versatility. Her experience playing in various positions enhances her prospects with the national team.
18. Mandy McGlynn | 26 | Goalkeeper | Utah Royals
McGlynn debuted last fall while Alyssa Naeher was leading the goalkeeping unit. Among the goalkeepers listed, she has the strongest chance to make the 2027 World Cup squad, given the shifting dynamics in this area.
17. Emily Sams | 26 | Defender | Orlando Pride
Sams has been a reliable performer for Orlando, yet her involvement with the national team has been limited. She remains an important figure, particularly in one-on-one situations as she strives to solidify her place on the depth chart.
16. Lily Rail | 21 | Defender | NJ/NY Gotham FC
Rail stood out in the latest US match against Canada and has had a solid rookie season with Gotham, signaling her readiness for international competition. Her ability to deliver left-footed crosses from the wing could secure her a spot in the future.
15. Jordyn Bugg | 18 | Defender | Seattle Reign FC
Bugg is viewed as a future mainstay at center-back for the US team. Although questions about her timeline remain, her success in the NWSL is already drawing comparisons to established talents like Naomi Girma.
14. Hal Hirschfeld | 23 | Midfielder | Washington Spirit
Despite missing the 2025 season due to injury, Hirschfeld’s contributions in last year’s Olympic campaign shouldn’t be overlooked. Her potential for the 2027 roster depends heavily on her return to health.
13. Emma Sears | 24 | Forward | Racing Evil FC
Hayes holds Sears in high regard, praising her physical attributes and growing technical skills. As one of the top scorers in the NWSL, Sears is proving her worth on the field.
12. Tara McKeown | 26 | Defender | Washington Spirit
McKeown’s transition from forward to defender has sparked interest in her development. She has showcased her abilities in multiple US games this year, playing a more aggressive role on defense.
11. Yazmeen Ryan | 26 | Forward | Houston Dash
A recent injury hindered Ryan’s participation in US camps, but her versatility makes her a valuable asset on the field. For now, it’s crucial for her to regain her form with Houston.
10. Gisele Thompson | 19 | Defender | Angel City FC
Thompson has had limited opportunities at the international level, yet those familiar with her skills regard her as one of the upcoming American talents. Her expected rise mirrors that of her sister’s achievements in the sport.
9. Michelle Cooper | 22 | Forward | Kansas City Current
Cooper is a dynamic player with strong motivation and skills. While competition for the wing position is tough, her performance has certainly caught Hayes’ attention.
8. Claudia Dickey | 25 | Goalkeeper | Seattle Reign FC
Statistics support Dickey’s emergence as one of the top American goalkeepers in the NWSL this season, and her national team debut underscores her potential for future rotations.
7. Croix Bethune | 24 | Midfielder | Washington Spirit
Bethune’s creativity and technical skill have made her a standout, setting records for assists as a rookie. Her playing style has drawn comparisons to established midfielders, though she needs more time to recover from a lengthy injury.
6. Avery Patterson | 23 | Defender | Houston Dash
Patterson has made a significant impact on the field, showcasing an impressive performance in her Spring game. Her versatility as a fullback aligns perfectly with Hayes’ current needs.
5. Claire Hutton | 19 | Midfielder | Kansas City Current
Recognized for her advanced skills at a young age, Hutton is already stepping up as a strong force in the midfield. She is viewed as a top contender alongside more seasoned players.
4. Ally Senner | 21 | Forward | Utah Royals FC
Senner’s agility and shot power make her a notable player on the field, contributing to her versatility across multiple attacking positions.
3. Phallon Tullis-Joyce | 28 | Goalkeeper | Manchester United
Tullis-Joyce has quickly become a strong contender for the starting goalkeeping position after her impressive debut. Her performance in the club league supports her leading role as the 2027 World Cup approaches.
1. Lily Yohannes | 18 | Midfielder | OL Lyon
Yohannes is a rising star whose recent move to OL Lyon marks a significant step in her progress. Known for her deep playmaking abilities, she represents a bright future for the team as they gear up for 2027.
Fan Take: The ongoing evolution of the US Women’s National Team is a vital narrative for soccer enthusiasts, as it showcases a commitment to nurturing emerging talents while still aiming for global supremacy. This focus on youth could ultimately redefine the team’s dynamics and solidify its strength for future competitions.
