The Pittsburgh Penguins officially dropped out of playoff contention for the first time in the 2025-26 season following a 2-1 overtime defeat to the Seattle Kraken on Saturday. After a strong October with an 8-2-2 record, the team struggled in November, posting a disappointing 2-4-3, losing leads in five games. While it’s harsh to say the Penguins are in freefall, their performance needs to improve quickly, especially with a tough stretch of games coming in December.
The team’s troubles largely stem from injuries to three key top-nine forwards—Rickard Rakell, Justin Brazeau, and Vir Koivunen—as well as dependable fourth-line player Noel Acciari, which has weakened both scoring and overall depth. Players like Connor Dewar and Kevin Hayes, typically bottom-six forwards, have been moved into top-six roles, but that hasn’t compensated for the missing production from Rakell and Brazeau. Scoring has become a major issue, highlighting the team’s urgent need for a spark.
In response, the Penguins should consider giving opportunities to their top young forward prospects. While there’s no guarantee these inexperienced players will immediately outperform current roster members, their youthful energy could invigorate the team. The team may soon have two roster spots available: Philip Tomasino was waived and cleared, allowing potential reassignment to Wilkes-Barre/Scranton (WBS), and rookie defenseman Harrison Brunicke could begin an AHL conditioning stint, opening up an NHL roster spot for up to 14 days.
Among the prospects, center Tristan Broz, right winger Avery Hayes, and winger Rutger McGroarty stand out. Broz, 23, has scored eight goals and tallied 13 points in 18 games at WBS, demonstrating versatility and defensive responsibility. Avery Hayes, who recently returned from injury, has three goals and six points in 12 AHL games and impressed during training camp playing alongside Sidney Crosby. McGroarty, after missing much of the early season due to injury, has shown promising speed and scoring ability in his recent games.
General Manager and President of Hockey Operations Kyle Dubas indicated that the team would be cautious about bringing McGroarty back too soon, considering his importance to the future. However, if McGroarty is ready, the Penguins might move him quickly into a top-six role. His ability to contribute on both special teams is a valuable asset.
Given the current challenges and the absence of key players, the Penguins need changes soon to revive their season. Introducing young talent could provide the necessary boost to help the team hold steady until their roster is healthier.
—
Fan Take: This development is crucial for hockey fans because it highlights how injuries and roster depth can dramatically alter a team’s fortunes, making the rise of young talent all the more exciting. The Penguins’ willingness to lean on prospects could not only reshape their season but also signal a broader shift toward developing youth in the NHL, influencing the sport’s future landscape.
