The 2025-26 season is still in progress, but it’s already time to analyze the report card for the summer transfer window of 2025, which included some hefty signings. Notable players like Alexander Isak, Florian Wirtz, and Benjamin Sesko were at the center of attention last summer. While their initial performances with new clubs haven’t quite met expectations, some other transfers have unexpectedly thrived. With the winter transfer window approaching, let’s review the top summer transfers of 2025.
10. Matheus Cunha
From Wolverhampton to Manchester United for $84.5 million (including add-ons)
Cunha has scored three goals in 16 appearances across the Premier League and EFL Cup for Manchester United. Under Ruben Amorim, he’s started the last nine Premier League games, netting twice in his last three outings. While he’s showing signs of improvement, there’s still room for growth. Grade: B
9. Victor Osimhen
From Napoli to Galatasaray for $87.5 million (including add-ons)
Though this transfer may not have created as much buzz as others, Osimhen has excelled on loan at Galatasaray since the summer of 2024, scoring 12 goals in 16 matches, including six goals in four Champions League games. He’s fitting in well and shows promise for a standout season ahead. Grade: A
8. Luis Diaz
From Liverpool to Bayern Munich for $88.5 million (including add-ons)
Luis Diaz stands out as the top performer on this list, having recorded 13 goals and seven assists in 22 appearances for Bayern Munich. His scoring rate of one goal every 137 minutes marks him as a significant contributor to Vincent Kompany’s squad. Grade: A+
7. Kai Havertz
From Crystal Palace to Arsenal for $91 million (including add-ons)
After nearly joining Tottenham, Havertz’s transfer to Arsenal late in the window created quite a stir. While he had some notable performances, including a hat-trick in the north London derby, fans expected more from him. Grade: B
6. Nick Waltemade
From Stuttgart to Newcastle for $93 million (including add-ons)
Waltamede has faced challenges due to Newcastle’s lackluster start, currently sitting 14th in the Premier League with 23 points. However, he’s scored nine goals and appears to be adjusting well to the Premier League. Grade: B-
5. Brian Mbuemo
From Brentford to Manchester United for $95 million (including add-ons)
Initially viewed skeptically, Mbuemo has impressed with seven goals in 17 matches, quickly becoming a crucial player for United. As he participates in the AFCON for Morocco, the club is eager to have him back. Grade: B+
4. Benjamin Sesco
From RB Leipzig to Manchester United for $99 million (including add-ons)
Unlike Mbuemo, Sesco has struggled to impact Manchester United significantly, with only two goals in 17 appearances. Nevertheless, at just 22, he has ample opportunity to turn things around. Grade: C-
3. Hugo Ekitike
From Eintracht Frankfurt to Liverpool for $106 million (including add-ons)
Ekitike has quickly established himself as a key player at Liverpool, racking up 11 goals in 24 matches. He’s arguably the club’s best signing this season, given the underwhelming performances of others. Grade: B+
2. Florian Wirtz
From Bayer Leverkusen to Liverpool for $157 million (including add-ons)
While Ekitike has shone, Wirtz’s high-profile transfer has not lived up to expectations yet; he only recently scored his first goal for Liverpool. Adapting to the Premier League can be challenging, and fans hope to see more from him soon. Grade: C-
1. Alexander Isak
From Newcastle to Liverpool for $168 million (including add-ons)
The Swedish striker has had a disappointing season thus far, netting only three goals and sidelined with a leg injury that could keep him out for months. With such a hefty price tag, he was expected to be a game-changer for Liverpool. Grade: D
Fan Take: These transfer evaluations highlight the unpredictability of player performance after high-stakes moves, a reality that resonates with soccer fans worldwide. The outcomes of these signings could redefine team fortunes and reshape league dynamics, making each transfer window a thrilling spectacle.
